I fished solo last Wednesday in an area known as The Dugway. I forgot my camera (that makes two trips in a row where I forgot my camera—the other trip was a week or so before when we fished for two days (1 in Idaho 1 in Wyoming—report later). The fishing was good and I caught around 15. The biggest was a smidgen over 13″ and most were about 11″. All of them were cutthroat caught on a dark elk hair caddis, size 14.
Friday I fished with Dan (and remembered my camera). We were going to try and fish Giraffe Creek and Preuss Creek on the Idaho/Wyoming border. They’re supposed to have some good populations of Bonneville cutthroat. We hit the road about 7:30.
I printed off some Google maps which we’ve found to be pretty good—up to that day. Two of the roads to Giraffe have been “removed.” One of them was blocked off with large rocks, and besides, it was barely big enough for ATVs. The other road has been plowed up and going back to its native state. I’ve been noticing this more and more. Has anyone else?
The third road to Giraffe involved a steep incline at the beginning with some serious slickrock. Dan’s 4×4 is still not operable, so after tire spinning attempt, we backed off.
We approached lower Preuss Creek, which isn’t supposed to have much in the way of fish, looking for a way to get to the upper creek. But it’s all private property. We tried one road to see if we could get to a point a few miles upcreek and then hike down to the creek, but after a mile or so we came across a “No Trespassing” sign. And the property owner (sheep rancher—baaaaaaaa!). He was a really nice guy but said he doesn’t grant access to the creek. He said that with the low water conditions for quite a few years in a row, there weren’t many fish left anyhow.
So we decided to head back to the Logan River. Which we got to around 12:00ish.
We stopped just above Red Banks and fished there for about 3 hours. I did pretty well collecting 15-20 fish and Dan caught about 6? I used the same elk hair caddis I used on Wednesday. Dan mostly used a beetle.
We moved upriver about a mile and continued fishing. I picked up another 10-15 and Dan caught about 7 more. So between the two of us we picked up 35-40 fish in about 6 hours of fishing. Like Wednesday, nothing too big with the biggest going around 14″ and most averaging in the 10″-12″ range. We each caught two browns and the rest were all Bonneville cutthroat.
One of my favorite catches of the day was when I spied a nice trout below these branches.
I promptly dropped into stealth mode
to win the prize ![]()
Of course, it’s even better watching it in hi-def video with a post-grunge surround track blaring (keep your eye on the red circled area from the above photo):
http://scarles.org/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/stalker.flv.
hmmmmmm…..
I’m not sure what happened to the HD or that soundtrack (or the handsome Brad Pittish model)…somebody musta hacked my site and left us with this crappy video instead.
One of the reasons I love fishing this particular area is the color of the river bottom, an incredible goldy color (and Dan’s fish is nice too):
Just another day fishing instead of working (although our workless days are numbered—only two weeks left—I hope you feel bad for us).







Let’s see-do I feel sorry for you?Let me think a minute.
Nope.
Sorry Scott, but that based on the fact that I am inherently jealous of anyone that gets to fish that much. Enjoy the rest of the summer as much as you can before you have to return to the real world!
It was worth a try. Real world……yeah, time to come back. If I have to.
It is a nice post though. The video is a nice touch.
If I have any luck at all I may get to make a trip out that way next year. Going on 3 years since I have been out there.
Thanks Harry. When you come, let me know!!
It’s getting close to the time I like to hit the Logan. I’ll be cruising that way soon. In fact, I’ll take a peek at the river when I head that way Thursday night on my way to Wyoming. Great post and pictures, keep ‘em coming!
Robert,
I know you like to solo, but if you’re feeling the need to have a fishing buddy, let me know.
I’d like to hook up before the fall leaves start hitting the water. I know school will start soon so maybe a Saturday in the next few weeks? I’ll keep you posted. I love the Logan in September.
School starts Aug 20. But fishing Saturdays are always good, school or no school. The only date I’m unavailable is Sept. 11-12.
Maybe I’ll take a weekday off (they owe me some vacation time) and go hit it before then. You share the secret spots, I’ll share the hoppers. Deal?
Deal! I have to be back at school on the 18th, Tuesday. So any time before then if you want to do a weekday.
Thanks for sharing a peek at your homewater. Really a lovely place, and the fish scale is always a function of the creek size. As for eradicating ATV roads, High Country News reports that it’s common on many of our western Forests. Sure wish they’d get rid of some on the Beaverhead-Deerlodge–it’s still going the other way, I think–new troads into my secret elk and hiking spots every year, zero enforcement against the perps.
It’s definitely crazy with the ATV access. The roads I’ve noticed them digging up are more of the regular dirt 2-track roads that your typical pickup can drive on, but leaving the ATV roads. I’ve seen a couple of ATV roads dug up or blocked off, but I’ve seen about 8 of the 2-track roads go.
I don’t see no video. Maybe I need to try it in not-firefox.
My congrats on the belly-stalk. And I can’t even see the spear wound on the fish. My home folks used to do that too, but they’d tickle the fish under the belly then snatch ‘im out the river. Of course, that was catfish, and they were pretty drunk.
My Big Missouri plans have scotched themselves this year, so I’ll have to live my western trout vicariously. Maybe in September, but that dang paying job keeps getting in the way.
d
EG2U
Dave,
Too bad about the Missouri plans and that paying job thing–I hate when adult responsibilities get in the way of the important things in life. Don’t they call that belly tickling thing “noodling,” or something?
OK suddenly I got video. Lovely work. I especially liked the play-by-play, including “Movie o…”
Dave
One of these days we’ll have real camera crews (with thousands of dollars worth of equipment) begging to follow us around and
shootfilm us. Until then, it’s just the cheesy stuff that the digital camera can capture at 15fps. I usually delete the sound because we can’t control our mouths when filming, but I though this was kind of funny.You should have spent the time to check out Thomas Fork Creek while you were over in that area. It can fish real well this time of year if you find the part with water.
Yeah, we crossed the river a couple of times and looked at it, but we had no idea which part to fish and where to get public access. Ideas?
Yeah, I like to go almost to the Wyoming border like you’re going to Star Valley. There is alot of private land but there is a part where it looks like there is an old highway on the east side of the road. I drive down there and fish upstream through the private land. You never have to get out of the water.
Thanks for the info. We turned west (left) on North Loop Road, literally at the border. We’ll have to look for the old road next time.